I am not going to so much take offense at Amber's remark about quiet players, because that is her opinion, but frankly there are many OOC reasons why a person may remain quiet. I do realize that this can slow the game progress, and thus draw attention towards said person for the means of speeding a game up to a comfortable pace for the majority of players, but that isn't a reason to base a vote IMO...we are given a time frame, and should be allowed that time frame to make our choices, speak out in the village, or NOT if we so choose. Using this against a player is ones own right, but it can discourage said players, especially newer players from being active at all, and stunt the game in in it's own rite.
This being said, I don't really think that Amber has painted a clear picture of her reasoning for changing her mind so constantly, it really is inconstant, and does not bode well...once again this is in MY opinion as a villager. We are also NOT supposed to use OOC knowledge to make our votes, so saying that having RPed with people in the past is not a valid reason for either voting or not for them.
I don't really know Amber or many players, but I am using IC feels to make my vote...for AmberStarfire