Alright, thanks for your patience. I probably spent way too much time thinking on this, but in the end, here is my decision.
I am voting to Lynch AmberStarfire
And here is why.
I fully believe at this point she is a villager. I think she came out with a wrong comment and everyone jumped on her. I think the wolves are getting off easy and that, for the most part, villagers have also voted to lynch Amber, thus putting me into this situation where if I vote to lynch I will look like a 'bad guy' when and if she comes up as a villager.
However, the village does have to work toward being a team. Amber has made it clear she's going to continue playing like a wild card, throwing her vote where she wants, and keeping the chaos going. Chaos breaks up the village. It distracts us. It keeps us from focusing on everyone else who is being shady in their own way, because we're all locked in on the way too obvious chaotic target. Wolves love this. I've been a wolf. I've let that happen. I've let the village vote for that person. I've spoken up for them. I've done all the things that I think are happening now.
We can't have Day Three turn out the same and hope to get anywhere as a village.
Finally, I considered the fact that by saving Amber, I was essentially vetting her to the village. Would we really continue to go after her again and waste the time and resources and a repeat of Day Two? Doesn't that make her the oh-so-perfect target for the wolves to actually change? Would the Seer really waste his time if there are other, bigger, stronger, more cunning fish to fry? I wouldn't, should I have that role. (which I don't). Which makes it all too easy for the wolves to let her slip into their pack. And if she does come up as a wolf? Well I'm the bad sheriff for letting her go.
Thus, It's my decision that by lynching her, she's no longer a threat to the village, even if she was a villager.
It isn't personal. I hope you understand. But at this point, with 16 villagers (soon to be 15 I assume), we need to play as a team in the best way I know possible.