"I know the terms of your agreement. What I wonder is, why would you two, complete strangers trust each other into making such a blind pact of faith regarding two people you know nothing about. Such an agreement is not only idiotic, it can keep a person safe that might just well be a werewolf. Think about it, if you were a werewolf, would you not come seeking for allies? Would you not be very happy to access just such a deal to make sure that you are never targeted by at least one person?" Evil said, seeming angry. "I cannot fathom for the life of me why you, the sheriff who is supposed to lead us and protect us, has chosen to accept a deal where you and someone else turn a complete blind eye to the fact that the other may not be trusted! I want to know why such a decision was made, and how on Earth you can expect the rest of us not to take it as suspicious! You have nothing on the fact that he is innocent, nothing but his mere word, and words in this world are only as useful as the information behind them and the information you have behind his words are zero, therefore his word should be taken the same way! It's just such a blind act of naivety that either you are a fool unworthy of being a Sheriff, or you know something about him we don't that makes you want to keep him alive, OR you have a reason to make sure that neither of you die while the rest of the village dies around you, perhaps even by your hand!" Evil continued on.
"Its a move which makes me want to see the both of you in the gallows! That is, unless, you can provide me some sort of explanation, some sort of proof from either part of you that gives me a reason to believe this decision was made with the safety of the entire village in mind! Because as I am standing right now by the info you give me, this decision was either made by a villain or a fool - neither of which deserve to be our sheriff."