Lol, that is very fair. I haven't exactly filled in all this information. ^_^;
With Elyse Swan (hehe, Swan's Swan) being a true believer, she doesn't really have a gift. Theoretically, true believers can go their entire lives being completely clueless to the fact that their belief makes them safer than their unbelieving mortal counterparts.
I think if you are looking for plot worthy gift stuff, you might be better off with a character with a minor talent.
Minor talent's vary, so what would you like her gift to be?