Totally smitten with this idea.
Have you found anyone yet? I'd love to play.
What's better then the cheer leading squad? The dance squad of course. Alissa Mortin became one of the most popular girls at her high school for being the leader of the dance squad, but she has also made great efforts to be known as a "good girl," which makes it easier for her to sneak under her parents radar, and all that more damning if a tape of her party were to be seen. Alissa usually wears miniskirts that come down to mid-calf and babydoll t-shirts that hug her form. She loves her black Jetta almost as much as she loves her golden retriever, Wilson.
She won't be willing to do anal at first. I'd like him to have to push her to get there (if you like). Toys are nice, but again I'd like him to have to threaten her with the tape to use unconventional things like plugs. It would also be sexy if he takes pictures of her, or tapes her undressing, having sex with him, etc. She can't really blackmail him with those since she's 18 and it looks consensual.
Do you have any kinks you'd want to explore? List 'em! I have a few I didn't mention, but like to hear someone else's first. I'm still new here, getting my feet wet. :3