Could you do something like once a month everybody can vote for their favorite story/game according to the categories they are in? There could be different groups as well like voting for the best story, the best writing, the best role-playing for example. The rules would be something like having to be at least x pages long so it would be fairly well established and a game could only win once a year or some limit maybe, though I hate to penalize a game if it's that good. And there doesn't need to be just a few judges. Instead the awards are chosen by us, the people that make E so great and a wonderful place to be, according to what we read. All would be needed is a thread or a pm account (to remain anonymous this would be the best idea) and a person to tally the votes and announce the winners. I like math and such, so I could maybe help with this part if we did something along these lines. Also, I could create a blank form to cut and paste according to the categories and classes to make everybody's vote look the same to be easier for the person tallying votes.