I like pic no. 2.
Plot! Maybe, in Generic Anime Fantasy Land the Good Boy purchases a house to run a business out of. In the house is a mirror where Bad Boy is imprisoned. He pleads for release, and good boy (being good) lets him out. Bad Boy molests the Good one as a reward for freeing him, then goes on his merry way.
That sound decent enough for a 1 shot?
Edit: I could play either side.