Trying to think.
I was kind of late to the party when it came to all that stuff. Wasn't until late High School. Most of my "puppy crushes" were reserved for real people. I remember this one girl... but not her name, used to annoy the heck out of her. Yeah... that's how I show affection, by being an annoying lil so-and-so.
I'm thinking that my first was, well, either Jessica Rabbit or the Charmed Sisters. (Yes, all 3. Especially when Paige showed up.) Well, no, I probably had a thing for Velma on Scooby Doo. I say "probably" because I'm not sure where that appeal came from, so it has to be something from my childhood somewhere. I mean, Velma is awesome! (And Daphne is annoying.) Cheetara was another, maybe.
I get over these things pretty quickly so it really is difficult for me to remember.