Okay. According to the original rules posted way back when, the game should really be over at this point. The game was first set up so that a single mutineer couldn't win. If everyone would like to stick with that, then the game is over and everyone's roles will be revealed.
However, I'm now thinking that rule isn't necessarily required... and in this case, where I believe there's no clear suspect for the third mutineer, it might be interesting to continue playing things out a little longer.
What say you all? End now, with the pirates victorious, or let the game continue another round or two?
In any case, given enough interest, I will start up another pirate-themed version, most likely, so the Fancy (or some sister ship) will sail again. :)