So, the major thing that brought you all down (and I'm sure Pers is well aware) was that Night included me in his PMs to form an alliance. I basically fed my fellow pirates every bit of information I could from that. Night was extremely thorough in his approach which was why he was taken out as soon as possible, and Val soon followed because she too was becoming a problem for us. We basically dismantled you guys from the inside because of that, and it was partially with Remi's help because the fact that he called me out by name early let Night believe I was innocent rather than guilty.
@King - My approach to you had a singular goal which was to get you to vote for someone other than myself or Pers because as long as the vacationer votes were spread, we would have the majority in votes to take one of you guys out. That plan soon fell apart, but Rel then helped by voting for Pers. At that point, the votes pretty much stayed the same, and even though BeMi used her ability, it delayed the inevitable. We only had one way to lose, and that was to pick the person that Pers was going to protect that night. We chose Rel because she voted with us and looked much more like a pirate than anyone else, so she was less likely to be protected. Our strategic choice paid off, and honestly, she was acting a lot like a pirate anyway. We didn't so much kidnap her as we inducted her into our pirate brotherhood.