So that was certainly an interesting game!
I think the hardest part for me was knowing that the rebel had been arrested (among other random things), and not being able to say anything.
Also I kept my spreadsheet updated the entire time this game, and kept adding new things based around what was going on discussion wise.
Just to show how crazy insane it got here's an image to show all the different pages in it:
Just for a fun little fact, KatKwik was the only pirate to have never been voted for.
No hard feelings, I hope, Persephone (and everyone else I lied to!). I had to lie my ass off in this game because, after Sunshine fingered me in round 1, I figured I was screwed. It was a huge stroke of luck that I converted Blythe the night after JM cleared him. Blythe told us all that JM was the Lookout, and I knew he would be investigating me that night.
I will say in regards to this, that I didn't fully trust you at all. My only issue was if you were trying to throw JM (a possible fellow pirate) under to cover yourself. That mainly came from this being my first time playing with JM and not knowing if that would be something the two of you would try. Also I will say that I'm annoyed how after I called Blythe out publicly, only one person voted for him (on two separate occasions, one of which was switched but still).
I should also mention Remi, you really tripped me up though. It's with how Ryven got into that big mass group message I made (Myself, Persephone, Valerian, RPGuy, Verasaille, and Ryven). When you had mentioned the people you had messaged, I honestly didn't think you'd put a pirate in that list (RPGuy, Verasaille, Persephone, NightOwl, and Ryven). At the point I made that group, I knew I wasn't a pirate, Persephone I figured wouldn't be based on her actions, same with Vera. RPGuy had came out as Night Watchman and had mentioned saving Valerian. The only person I couldn't cover was Ryven but since everyone else was clear, why wouldn't he be? And when I had figured "There's something odd about how he's posting but not interacting here, even to say "I don't trust any of you"" I was kidnapped and unable to do anything about it.
Ah well! Well played pirate!