How exactly have I been quiet? o.o; I've made many posts for someone who's been working. =P
Well I will clarify that I didn't vote for you because you were quiet. I voted for you because 1. you threw away your sheriff vote and 2. None of your posts including this one have actually been very helpful. More they've seemed like a distraction. Maybe if you clarified a bit where you stand right now and why you voted the way you did for sheriff I can be convinced to change. I would have liked more feedback on my comments, but the deadline came up and no one had responded, so I needed to toss down a vote.
I am still suspicious of Guy. Am I the only one? Someone tell me why I shouldn't be, he said we should lynch people without any knowledge. I mean, if you're just rolling the dice and hoping for the best, you're most likely going to kill a cam member.
Most people aren't suspicious of him because he claimed a role and no one else came out to dispute him as of yet. As far as the lynching with no information, that's an opinion a number of people have held and have done so in past games no matter what side they are on. I can agree to disagree, but because I -know- their habits and patterns, I can't say that lends them to being suspicious because they have held the same stance in the past.
It's also shade that I said hours ago we're past the deadline but you still haven't voted, as though you're waiting to see just what everyone does before making a decision. SHADY.
So.. right now, since she is not more forthcoming I feel I must cast my vote for Christa since it sounds like a perfect way to get the good Camarilla to protect her even as she twists a knife in their back. If she chooses to be a bit more forthcoming on who she is, provided she does not have a challenger to that role, my vote for her should be considered instantly withdrawn.
I see the merit in going after the quiet ones. I really do. That being said, of the two Andy mentioned, Rel
is a lot more experienced at forum games than Christa is, and this is her first mafia. I can get behind the newb excuse for Christa for a short time. I really feel it's in our best interest to NOT lynch her. That being said, I'm not sure right now I want to vote for Rel, even though Amber's reasoning that she isn't being active thus isn't helping either way holds some merit.
Lol. And one of my first posts gets me a vote. Haha. This is another reason I was being quiet, but I guess that's over and done with. I just meant that I don't know if it's really a good idea to give out our roles or not. I feel like if I do, that's a big mistake. I'm really unsure of how to proceed at this point.
I've played Mafia in RL, but this is the first time in a forum, so this is quite confusing to me. Sorry.
I would not hand out your role, especially not in public. At this stage of the game, it's better to start assessing people for their honesty, looking at their voting patterns, watching who votes for who. While Guy did hand out his, he isn't a risky threat to sabbat, assuming he's telling the truth. He can't provide information or hurt them in any way. He's actually more of a help to them. A third of the players are also Caitiff, meaning that anyone claiming Caitiff can't really be verified. I most definitely don't agree with Andy's assessment about claiming roles and only would if it was totally necessary (IE: last game Remi was on the chopping block and revealed his role. We changed our votes to save him and lynch someone else. He would have died anyway, so at that point it was a good move.)
At this moment, my vote is to Remiel. Guy's post pretty much lines up with my thoughts. Voting nobody day when, even though he knows it only favors the Sabbat and then his reasoning for me... his tactics this game have just been suspicious.
You of all people know that Remi is too good of a player to just come out and look shady shade. I'm dead sure Remi has voted nobody in the past on the first round for the exact same reasons I did - that the odds aren't in our favor on the first day without ANY information. Now, at the very least, we do have some information. Someone saw something last night, and we have two more days of discussion. Yes, his reason for you (You're always bad) is poor and shouldn't be used. So I won't be using it, but I still don't see throwing this much against Remi so quickly.
I would vote Andy over Remi, mostly because I feel Andy's erratic voting could send the wrong person to the block, or start a trend towards one direction when we need to go another, given that often people start to vote along the lines of others. (In fact, I think Andy is experiencing this right now), and I don't think he's a special role. He claimed Caitiff, so he's either a Caitiff or a Sabbat playing poorly. I lean to first, but already he's lost a lot of trust and could be dangerous.
However, I really don't think we should vote for Remiel, and knowing that our sheriff would pick him in a tie means really REALLY thinking over voting for him.
Quick Summary since Blythe is busy:
Andy - 3 (Rel, Christa, Yugi)
Leslie - 1 (Mint)
Madame P - 2 (Remy and Andy... I think that was his last official vote)
Rel - 1 (Amber)
Christa - 1 (Ink)
Remiel - 2 (MP and Geeklet)
Missing: Guy, Leslie, Seranova, Persephone