Yeah, I had Vera pegged as the Murderer within two clues, but I had absolutely no idea whatsoever that Madame Professor was the Accomplice. I totally thought it was Derwaysh. <_<
And that is why more information isn't always good information. So many of you were sure of Vera at the beginning of the game, a few elimination guesses and you'd have her.
I actually lost a game last night in 3 clues and one guess. Half the table had poison items on it, so I went with mine, Venomous Snake. My evidence was "plastic", which shows a water bottle on the card.
First clue was poison. No big deal, saw that ckmjng, next clue was woods. That narrowed it down to a small hajdful, but there was also plenty of evidence to fit that and maybe I could convince the group that woods was referring to the insects or dirt evidence that other potential prisoners had.
Third clue was the perfect draw: Evidence left behind, Synthetic
. I was so fuvked, and I knew it. Before I could fit a word in, someone spoke up. "If it's guy, the only combo that really works for that is Snake and plastic, may as well guess him and eliminate him as a suspect if that's not it..." And that was game.