I can't really say much while I'm also playing on a team, but there are reasons out there why a FSN would hold back on giving clues, or not give several in rapid succession.
Incorrect, I'm afraid.
Well, damn. That's both of my prime suspects shot down. I could have sworn one of those would be our murderer...
Guess it's back to the drawing board.
Remember hat the locations are not limited to the ones Guyg has listed. There are other location boards which might have fit well with Cosmetic Mask but he chose Woods.
But the location is Woods not Woodland Spa.
This is a pretty valid valid point here about the locations.
I'm sure there are plenty of spas in some Woods, in fact I can totally see that being a relaxing atmosphere. However, again, this is one of those risks of being "too clever" and looking too deep into things here. TRPG wants us to get it, and so we have to look for first impressions. And when I see "Woods" my mind doesn't immediately jump to a woodland spa, especially not given the context of the game. No, I immediately picture a dense forest. Creepy pine trees looming overhead. Fog on the ground. Y'know, classic murder/horror forests, not enchanted forests.
So, anyway, back to business. Now, I don't think Yugi is completely off the hook here. I think it's PLAUSIBLE that it is Yugi with the Axe and Cosmetic Mask. However that just leaves out too many clues for my liking (particularly the Water Stain).
I think our most likely bet right now is Madame Professor with the Fish Hook and Bracelet, because that can still be tied in with pretty much every single clue (with the exception of Smell, but even that could sort of be tied in).
Honestly though, with three guesses gone already I suddenly feel a lot less confident about our chances here.