Hm. That's what I thought too, but it may be the first.
With Froggy I was the last to get it, had the title for a week then it bounced to CattyCutie who was the first. I tied it again the other day and no difference.
But then Apples, Andy was the last to get it and he's got the title. So i'm really not sure.
Tied first in Monster Munch this morning but KG's still got it.
Does it depend on the game?