A 16yo pretty boy is gay, but as never so much as humped with another boy. He is too shy to hit on another boy. He is too scared to join the LGBT club at his school. The last thing he wants to do is for it to get around that he goes to his knees. Then one day he finds a list of everyone who has attended at least one dance, party or other LGBT event laying on a table in the library. He quickly photo copied the list and replaced the original on the table and hurried home.
On the list was the school pothead. He wasn't that hot, but maybe if he rolled around with him in bed a little he could get free weed. A jock, a class president, a slacker, a chubby buddy of his and another kid who he thought of as almost as cute as himself. One of us would be the main boy. The other would play his chubby buddy. Others would be NPCs.