-2 isn't that bad, I don't think. We're not talking SS Marquis De Sade here; a crew member who inflicts actual breakage on a CO is probably going to wish he'd never been born after getting whatever punishment Phillips hands out - that sort of environment is going to require equally brutal discipline, well beyond something tame like 'forfeit your chips'. The CO's aren't going to be lying in pools of their own filth or starved/sleep-deprived, they'll be give exactly what they need to remain healthy and functional for use, including regimenting 'recovery' periods if needed. But nothing more than that; they are organic machines to be used to keep the crewmen psychologically healthy.
And yeah...if there's any need to force a CO to begin with, something has gone wrong. Either the CO is refusing to do their job and thus in violation, or the crewman is trying to get free sex and thus effectively 'stealing' from the company.