Manning didn't do well at all last year until the last game of the regular season before he went all Superman. I'm not buying stock in him just yet. He beat the Patriots, yes, definitely. He plays on offense, though, not defense, so he didn't beat Brady. Umenyiora, Tuck, and Strahan beat Tom Brady. Brady's own offensive line beat him, too. This year, Manning's got three, count 'em, THREE top shelf running backs and a crazy good offensive line. Hell, I could probably hit a slant pass with that supporting cast. Seriously though, if anyone can screw up a setup like that, it's Eli Manning. He already had one bad game this year when they lost to the Browns, so there's no reason to think he's golden all of a sudden.