Apologies, I'm still reviewing apps and trying to make up my mind. I'll try to step it up, but...Decisions, decisions!
In a way it's significantly easier in a game with a bunch of classes and a bunch of distinct party roles: you can easily say 'Well, we need at least 1 from column a, 2 from column b, and then white rice of fried rice or chow mein.'
With only three 'classes' a lot more devolves to 'how well do I think this character and player will work well with others/setting ideas?'
Going to go re-read them all again and see if anything new jumps out at me helpfully. When I've made up my mind, I'll announce that acceptees will have received PMs and the forum has been created and thank the rest of you for your interest.
But it has been a busy week, it's a difficult choice, and I haven't made up my mind yet.