7/10...not a baseball fan, nor much of a tanktop-sleeveless type of shirt type. Like the pose though.
I don't feel it was less than what she deserved. I don't give points, usually, based on the person themselves. I try not to be harsh, but if the avatar is not to my liking, then I would feel as if I were lying by giving it a full 10/10. I do always try to find something about the avatar to like though.