I'm a massive fan of Shinsuke Nakamura, especially since he changed up his gimmick in the last two years. However Scott Lost was my favourite wrestler for the longest time, especially since he was criminally overlooked by a fanbase that was so high on Punk, Hero, Danielson et al. Lost was easily as good as all of the "big" indy wrestling names in the ring, and even better than a good number of them, however he never got the recognition I think he deserved. Probably because he was tied so heavily to PWG as one of the guys running the company as well as performing in it.
Also he's a pretty nice guy, which isn't as easy to find in wrestling as it could be.Scott Lost
I'm a massive fan of Joshi (Japanese women's wrestling) so you'd think my favourite female wrestler would be even harder to pin down, but funnily enough it isn't. For me there's only one choice of the currently active women, nobody even comes close to Kana as a complete package.Kana tribute - most dangerous