D'eon was one I was going to get into, but then I read further into the series' premise. It has nice styling....I like the attire and such characters have on (for example), but I have been hesitant because I don't know if I'd really be into its story.
I could list every single anime title I have seen / own to give folks an idea what I'm into, but that would take forever. I made one up for an attempted RP request that went nowhere here one time, but I lost the file.
Your situation reminds me much how I felt with Revolutionary Girl Utena. I won't soon forget how over-hyped that series was back in 1998-1999 when its U.S. release run started. I own the first couple DVDs (the old Central Park versions with the horrible audio....one of the openings' audio tracks phases in and out, and like most all CPM DVDs of the time, the video is VHS quality....yes, THAT bad).. But A/V issues aside, it just didn't grab me. I didn't get the hype, and shelved that show after 13 episodes, basically covering the first arc of the series.
Ditto Fullmetal Alchemist, and Bleach. Not quite my cup of tea.