So I was watching the movie The Village again, and I was thinking about a game based on that story, but not holding entirely true to it. I was thinking more along the lines of a human settlement of about a hundred people in a clearing somewhere in the middle of an isolated forest; except the monsters, this time they are real. The original settlers, now the few living Elders struck a bargain with 'those of whom we do not speak.' The humans keep to their village, and the monsters stay in the forests. But something has angered the creatures, and the first signs of their displeasure are discovered when some of the cattle are found mutilated.
While the creatures are real in the idea, I'd rather not get all carried away with some crazy fantasy setting. Maybe there is magic, but it'd be extremely rare and barely understood, otherwise lets not get all elf/dwarfy and everyone has chain mail and a broad sword stuff with this one.
I'd really rather find someone to run a game like this for a small number of players or even just myself, than try and run it myself, so if anyone is interested, let me know.