Tavern of Ghosts

Started by Xillen, June 05, 2009, 11:06:05 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Marguerite

*R.R*A.A*O.O*Wiki*Bordello*Whip and Apple*
You Keep On Crying, Baby, I'll Bleed You Dry
Mar Is Currently: Taking On Threads
Check My Absence Thread For Updates, Thank You

Ryven

I'm a carnivore at heart.  ::)

Marguerite

-Smirks-

Yes, we all know how you love...meat.
*R.R*A.A*O.O*Wiki*Bordello*Whip and Apple*
You Keep On Crying, Baby, I'll Bleed You Dry
Mar Is Currently: Taking On Threads
Check My Absence Thread For Updates, Thank You

Ryven

*laughs*  I do, indeed.

Marguerite

-Hugs and smiles-

Same here.
*R.R*A.A*O.O*Wiki*Bordello*Whip and Apple*
You Keep On Crying, Baby, I'll Bleed You Dry
Mar Is Currently: Taking On Threads
Check My Absence Thread For Updates, Thank You

Desan

And I don’t really give a f-ck, and my excuse is that I’m young.


Ryven

Am I the only one that thinks the change in the healer's power is a bit skewed in the villager's favor?

I mean, by making it a 50% chance of working and the ability to use it on every villager once...there really is no reason for the healer to ever say 'no' when given the option to use their ability.  It's basically like saying that the werewolves have a 50% chance of successfully eating each person on their first try without having the role of the healer at all.

In my opinion, I thought it much more strategic to make it a 1 shot deal with 100% success because it will make the healer decide who to save.  If they know who the seer or guardian is and they haven't used their power, they will more likely save them if they get attacked than someone else.

Also, if the healer's ability has only a 50% chance of success, why not the seer or guardian as well?

Don't misunderstand this as a complaint.  I'm just observing and giving feedback as well as asking others what they think.

Desan

Once per player?

So if the healer uses it on the seer/guardian once, then that's it, they can never use it on the person again? And if then, if they use it and it "fails" then they still can't use it on the same person?

I agree with Ryven, if the healer gets 50% chance hit or miss, so should the werewolves, seer, and guardian. But with all these hit/misses, it'll just drag the game longer won't it?

And I don’t really give a f-ck, and my excuse is that I’m young.


Ryven

The werewolves are already getting a 50% change because of the healer, and yeah...it will only drag it on longer which, in itself, gives the villagers an advantage because they have more time to figure out who the WW's are.

Autumn Sativus

Quote from: Sir Desan on July 21, 2009, 04:26:33 PM
So if the healer uses it on the seer/guardian once, then that's it, they can never use it on the person again? And if then, if they use it and it "fails" then they still can't use it on the same person?
If they fail or succeed they've used their chance. One try per player no matter the outcome.
Us against the world
Just a couple sinners making fun of hell


~~A&A(updated March 2021)~~Tales~~Wants~~O&O~~Wiki~~

Autumn Sativus

I'm tweaking the game and roles to play fairly based on my view. So just because that is the rule in this game, that doesn't mean it will be the rule forever. Our healer has not abused their power, and so long as that continues I don't think that this rule is unfair.

Please recall that I also gave the werewolves a one man lead by making it night first when most games begin with day... I'm not in favor of one side of the other, I'm just trying to find my own way to run the game it a way that plays out fairly.
Us against the world
Just a couple sinners making fun of hell


~~A&A(updated March 2021)~~Tales~~Wants~~O&O~~Wiki~~

Scott

arrives exhailing smoke and waves to all the groovy dead folks :)

Marguerite

-Smacks the dead wolf-

Evil, wolf.
*R.R*A.A*O.O*Wiki*Bordello*Whip and Apple*
You Keep On Crying, Baby, I'll Bleed You Dry
Mar Is Currently: Taking On Threads
Check My Absence Thread For Updates, Thank You

Ryven

Don't hate on the furry ones.  :-(

Marguerite

You were the one trying to eat the rest of us, Ryven.

-Nods-
*R.R*A.A*O.O*Wiki*Bordello*Whip and Apple*
You Keep On Crying, Baby, I'll Bleed You Dry
Mar Is Currently: Taking On Threads
Check My Absence Thread For Updates, Thank You

LadySky

*snickers and smooches Scott*
I dreamed a dreamed, life has killed the dream I dreamed. So....I dream a NEW DREAM!!! never let them see you cry.

LadySky

*flops down totally bewildered*

I really thought Saku was the seer!

Totally confused now ppl!
I dreamed a dreamed, life has killed the dream I dreamed. So....I dream a NEW DREAM!!! never let them see you cry.

Ryven

She obviously played it well, making everyone think she was.

Scott

I thought she was :) *wipes egg off his face*

Marguerite

Wait, Saku is not the seer?

-Glances and is amazed-

She fooled me.
*R.R*A.A*O.O*Wiki*Bordello*Whip and Apple*
You Keep On Crying, Baby, I'll Bleed You Dry
Mar Is Currently: Taking On Threads
Check My Absence Thread For Updates, Thank You

Teno

I think that was the intention :P

Teno

You know... when you nom on someone... IT'S NOT SUPPOSED TO BE THAT MUCH!!

Kip

*looks sadly at Teno*  The village barely knew you.

"You say good start, I say perfect ending. 
This world has no heart and mine is beyond mending."
~Jay Brannan~

"Am I an angel or a monster?  A hero or a villian? Why can't I see the difference?"
~Mohinder Suresh~

Autumn Sativus

Blech mornings! I hate mornings!

*Stomps off to work*
Us against the world
Just a couple sinners making fun of hell


~~A&A(updated March 2021)~~Tales~~Wants~~O&O~~Wiki~~

Kip

Quote from: Saffron on July 27, 2009, 06:25:31 AM
Blech mornings! I hate mornings!

*Stomps off to work*

*hands Saff a cookie and caffeine and considers it wise not to mention that he has four weeks off starting next week*  <3

"You say good start, I say perfect ending. 
This world has no heart and mine is beyond mending."
~Jay Brannan~

"Am I an angel or a monster?  A hero or a villian? Why can't I see the difference?"
~Mohinder Suresh~